2024
Tyson Meade, defense, Rondout Valley - St. John's
Drew Cornax, midfield, Lourdes - Marist
2023
Sean Fogarty, defense, Archbishop Stepinac - LIU
Mike Rettberg, attack, Mahopac - NJIT
Brandon Blenk, midfield, Iona Prep - Siena
Bryan Stensrud, attack, Arlington - Springfield
Joey Connolly, goalie, Hendrick Hudson - Arcadia
Connor Baia, faceoff, Kennedy Catholic - Catholic
Colin McManus, defense, Byram Hills - Endicott
2022
Michael Harney, attack, Mahopac - Army
Benny Rakower, midfield, Byram Hills - Bowdoin
Ryan Challice, attack, Pleasantville - Trinity
Marty Stewart, defense, Hendrick Hudson - Penn College
Jason Fastiggi, faceoff, Yorktown - Conn College
Jacob Nudelman, defense, Ardsley - Clark
Gavin Blenk, midfield, Iona Prep - Siena
Josh Bank, midfield, Salisbury - Ithaca
Nick Graap, attack, Lakeland - Endicott
Liam McAlary, midfield, Archbishop Stepinac - SUNY Oswego
Jake Strobel, midfield, White Plains - Manhattanville
Nicholas Armogida, attack, White Plains - Manhattanville
Rudy DeFilippis, defense, White Plains - Ohio Northern
Jake D'Andrea, goalie, Hill Academy - Vermont
Luca Schettino, midfield, Salisbury - SUNY Geneseo
Anthony Guglielmo, midfield, Yorktown - Florida Southern
Alex Farben-Griggs, defense, White Plains - SUNY Potsdam
Will White, goalie, Pelham - Ohio Wesleyan
Vincent Santelia, defense, Horace Greeley - Wagner
Nicolas Conetta, midfield, Lakeland - Saint Leo
Vincent Cappelli, defense, Yorktown - Springfield
Nick Spista, goalie, White Plains - SUNY Maritime
Jack Herman, faceoff, White Plains - Lynn University
2021
Jake Abraham, goalie, Hackley - Haverford
Andrew Llamas, midfield, Westlake - Cortland
Matthew Sardo, midfield, Westlake - Mount St Mary (Maryland)
Luke Phillips, midfield, Stepinac - Washington
Jack O'Reilly, defense, John Jay - Clark
Shaine Luzietti, defense, Newtown - Marist
2020
Eddie Dunhill, attack, Pelham Memorial – Skidmore
Alex Cottler, defense, Horace Greeley – Hartwick
Coby Rozencwaig, midfield, Scarsdale - Clark
Michael Propersi, midfield, Norwalk - Ithaca
JT Turnquist, midfield, Ossining - Wagner
Marco Fernandez, midfield, Wappingers - Gordon
Kofi Samuels, goalie, McCallie - Yale
2019
Mac Coughlin, defense, New Rochelle – Siena
Zach DeBraz, defense, Pelham Memorial – Manhattanville
Nick Meier, midfield, Bethel – Post
Bennett Smith, attack, Monroe-Woodbury – SUNY Poly
Michael Swift, midfield, New Rochelle – Plattsburgh State
Pat Doherty, midfield, Pleasantville - Wesleyan
Jason Weiss, defense, Somers - Alfred
2018
James Daniele, midfield, Pleasantville – Utica
Jack Fitzgerald, goalie, Pleasantville – Bentley
Layton Harrell, midfield, Newtown – Stony Brook
Nick Lambiase, midfield, Irvington – Manhattanville
Connor Sullivan, defense, Darien – Endicott
Miles Tillman, midfield, White Plains – Quinnipiac
2017
Harrison Hefferean, midfield, Norwalk – Montclair State
Nick LaFranco, defense, Norwalk – Springfield
Joey LaRacca, midfield, Norwalk - Montclair State
Matt Leader, attack, Fox Lane – Providence
James McKenna, defense, Pearl River – Oneonta
Brian Quick, goalie, Norwalk – St. John's
Dylan Walsh, attack, Pearl River – Misericordia