2020

Eddie Dunhill, attack, Pelham Memorial – Skidmore
Alex Cottler, defense, Horace Greeley – Hartwick

2019

Mac Coughlin, defense, New Rochelle – Siena
Zach DeBraz, defense, Pelham Memorial – Manhattanville
Nick Meier, midfield, Bethel – Post
Bennett Smith, attack, Monroe-Woodbury – SUNY-Poly
Michael Swift, midfield, New Rochelle – Plattsburgh State

2018

James Daniele, midfield, Pleasantville – Utica
Jack Fitzgerald, goalie, Pleasantville – Bentley
Layton Harrell, midfield, Newtown –  Stony Brook
Nick Lambiase, midfield, Irvington  – Manhattanville
Connor Sullivan, defense, Darien – Endicott
Miles Tillman, midfield, White Plains – Quinnipiac

2017

Harrison Hefferean, midfield, Norwalk – Montclair State
Nick LaFranco, defense, Norwalk – Springfield
Joey LaRacca, midfield, Norwalk - Montclair State
Matt Leader, attack, Fox Lane – Providence
James McKenna, defense, Pearl River – Oneonta
Brian Quick, goalie, Norwalk – St. John's
Dylan Walsh, attack, Pearl River – Misericordia